I love chocolate, but I am very particular about the brand of chocolate. The answer to why I never eat most organic fair trade chocolate, is that most chocolate contains soy lecithin – even the best organic fair trade brands.
Even the best organic, sustainable, fair trade chocolate contains soy lecithin.
What is wrong with these companies? Don’t they know that even organic soy lecithin is a waste product?
Soy lecithin is an ingredient in much more than just chocolate. It is used as an emulsifier to keep water and fat from separating in products such as margarine, peanut butter, chocolate, ice cream, coffee creamers, salad dressings and infant formulas.
It is ubiquitous in supplements and packaged foods — if it comes in a box or a bottle it probably has soy lecithin.
Soybean lecithin comes from sludge left after crude soy oil goes through a degumming process. It is a waste product that contains solvents and pesticides with color ranges from dirty tan to reddish brown. Manufacturers then bleach it to make it the more appealing light yellow color.
Additionally, let’s not forget that 90% of the soybeans in this country are now genetically modified and very heavily sprayed with glyphosate herbicides (compliments of Monsanto).
Consequently, most of the soy lecithin is from genetically modified soy which is full of chemicals that are truly poisonous.
The action of glyphosate is incredibly damaging to everything it touches.
It is a poison plain and simple.
We use a chemical that is a poison (glyphosate) to raise crops. The crops are fed to livestock. The livestock get sick and we have to call the vet who uses chemicals to treat them.
The chemicals from the food and the chemicals from the treatment are now in the meat of the livestock that humans eat. The humans get sick and go to the hospital where they use chemicals to treat them.
Break the cycle.
Avoid all genetically modified products. Avoid all soy products because they are almost 100% genetically modified. Avoid soy lecithin because it comes from genetically modified soy and is an ingredient in many commercial products.
Soy lecithin became more available in the early 1900’s when companies realized that they could use this waste from soybean processing – soybean oil refining was a fast growing industry – and resell it as soybean lecithin. In previous years, lecithin was derived from egg yolks. It is very difficult to find lecithin from eggs at this point.
According to Dr. Kaayla Daniel, the author of The Whole Soy Story,
Scientists hired to find some use for the substance cooked up more than a thousand new uses by 1939.
Since it is a natural product, it isn’t bad for you – right? After all, it is found in the cells of all living organisms.
It is bad for you and since it is in everything, you are likely getting more more than you think.
Health claims have been made for soy lecithin since the 1920’s. These include benefits for atherosclerosis, multiple sclerosis, liver cirrhosis, gall stones, psoriasis, eczema, scleroderma, anxiety, tremors and brain aging.
It makes sense that it might be beneficial because our bodies use phospholipids in the structure of every cell membrane and along every nerve cell. However, the phospholipids found in soy are considerable lower than those found in egg yolks.
It was popularized in the 1960’s and 70’s by Adele Davis and other writers and became the latest health panacea.
In 2001 it was backed by the FDA and allowed to be notated on labels as being a good source of choline. Research from the University at Chapel Hill and at Duke University backed up the claim for soy as being a good source of choline along with eggs and milk products.
Phosphatidylcholine is a popular supplement that alternative practitioners use to prevent and reverse dementia, improve cognitive function, increase human growth hormone release, and to treat brain disorders such as damage from stroke.
Phosphatidyl Serine is another supplement that supports brain function and mental acuity as well as sleep disorders.
However, I would think long and hard about using these supplements if the lecithin is derived from soy. Typically it is not sourced from organic soy.
Another phosphotidyl substance worth mentioning is lysophosphatidylethanolamine (LPE), which the FDA has approved for fruit ripening and shelf life extension.
Just another additive with dangerous potential effects.
The manufacture of soy lecithin theoretically eliminates all of the soy proteins which would eliminate the allergenicity. However, there is always minute amounts of soy protein remaining in lecithin as well as in soy oil. This fact makes it very difficult for people with allergies or those who are highly sensitive to soy.
For some people, even the tiniest molecule of soy can set off an immunological response and trigger a flareup of symptoms. It is just as reactive as gluten and because, it is in everything, those folks need to be extra careful which commercial foods they eat.
In the early 1990’s I fell under the spell of the joy of soy. Now that I know better, I wouldn’t go near it with a ten foot pole. Read about my 7 Reasons to Avoid Soy Like The Plague.
There are other problems with soy. First off, it is a goitrogen.
That means it will have a negative affect on the thyroid gland. Soy contains substances called phytates, lectins and enzyme inhibitors which make it very difficult to digest.
Additionally it soy contains isoflavones that mimic the effects of estrogen and can be very dangerous for children and adults to consume.
Soy lecithin is used in chocolate as an emulsifier.
However, chocolate can be made without it. There are several brands of chocolate that manage to produce fantastic chocolate without any lecithin (or other additives) and that taste great.
When I am not making my own homemade chocolate, I prefer to buy a commercial product that has as few additives as possible.
If you take a look at all the ingredients in every bar of chocolate in a store like, for instance, Whole Foods, you will not find one that doesn’t have soy lecithin. Even the organic, fair trade, sustainable brands all have soy lecithin.
I enjoy some chocolate now and then, but I am very careful which one I buy. Mostly, I make it at home – so easy from pure, organic, fair trade cacao powder, cacao butter and a little honey.
Here are three suppliers of chocolate that make it without soy lecithin:
See comments below for other brands that do not contain soy lecithin.
Of course all sweets should be eaten in moderation and the 80/20 (or 90/10) rule can apply here. I’ve given up lots of commercial products because they contain too many ingredients that are just bad. O
f course, once in a while it certainly wouldn’t be harmful to have some of these additives (unless you are super sensitive or on a healing diet very strictly.) However, soy and all of its derivatives is a dangerous and poisonous food.
This poison is non-negotiable. No soy lecithin for me. What about you? If you know of a good brand that makes chocolate without soy lecithin, leave a comment and let me know!
Soy Lecithin: From Sludge to Profit